Best Insurance Executive Search Firms: 11 Compared by Hire Type

The best insurance executive search firm is the one that already knows the seat you are filling.
- For a carrier CEO, board director, or C-suite hire, start with The Jacobson Group, Spencer Stuart, Korn Ferry, or Alpha Apex Group.
- For a leader at a private equity-backed broker, MGA, or insurtech, JM Search and Kaye/Bassman fit that deal-driven hiring pattern best.
- For a chief actuary, call DW Simpson.
- For Lloyd's and London-market leadership, call Stanton Chase.
This guide compares 11 insurance executive recruiters, grouped by the type of hire each one handles best. Every entry covers what the firm does, who it fits, who it does not fit, where it is based, and one insurance mandate you can check yourself.
After the list, you will find how an insurance search runs, what it costs, and the questions that separate a strong firm from a weak one before you sign.
Which Insurance Executive Recruiter Should You Call First?
Call the firm whose network already covers your seat. Use this table to build a shortlist of two or three, then read the full entries below.
How We Evaluated These Executive Search Firms for the Insurance Industry
We scored each firm on six weighted criteria, then grouped the firms by the hire type where they scored highest. Rankings inside each group follow the weighted score.
We checked every firm against its own insurance practice page, consultant profiles, and recent press releases or trade coverage.
Disclosure: Alpha Apex Group publishes this guide and is included on this list. We placed it using the same criteria applied to every other firm.
Best Executive Search Firms for Insurance Carrier CEO, Board, and C-Suite Roles
These six firms run the senior-most insurance searches: CEO succession, board directors, and the functional C-suite at carriers, mutuals, and reinsurers.
1. The Jacobson Group

The Jacobson Group has recruited only in insurance since 1971, making it the deepest single-industry bench on this list. Its executive search practice handles board, CEO, and C-suite roles across property and casualty, life, health, and reinsurance, and the same firm also runs professional recruiting, temporary staffing, and interim experts.
That mix matters when a carrier needs an interim chief claims officer while a permanent search runs.
Jacobson also publishes a recurring Insurance Labor Market Study, so its partners bring current hiring and compensation data to the role-scoping conversation.
- Best for: Mutual and regional carriers that want an insurance-only firm for CEO and C-suite searches, with interim cover available.
- Not a fit for: Insurtechs recruiting technology leaders from outside insurance.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance-only; Chicago. Named to both of Forbes' recruiting lists, one of 51 firms to make both.
2. Spencer Stuart

Spencer Stuart pairs a dedicated insurance practice with a board and CEO practice that has run for more than 40 years.
Its insurance consultants cover carriers, reinsurers, brokers, retirement businesses, and insurtechs, and one Philadelphia-based consultant's client base runs from large global insurers to private equity-backed MGA rollups.
For a carrier board, that range means one firm can run a CEO succession plan, assess internal candidates, and recruit independent directors with insurance experience.
It was retained by WellPoint, then the second-largest US health insurer, to lead its 2012 CEO search.
- Best for: Public carriers and large mutuals running CEO succession or board refreshment.
- Not a fit for: Single director-level hires at a regional broker.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Dedicated insurance practice within a multi-industry firm; Chicago.
3. Alpha Apex Group

Alpha Apex Group runs insurance executive search as part of a cross-industry practice that also covers technology, finance, and private equity leadership. That adjacency across sectors allows the team to deliver viable candidate profiles in just 72 hours.
Its insurance searches target underwriting and risk leaders, claims executives, and compliance-minded C-suite hires. Its assessment weighs insurance expertise against leadership capability and cultural fit (via a proprietary Executive Capital Allocation Scorecard™).
The firm's structural difference is model flexibility: retained executive search, recruitment process outsourcing, and fractional or interim executives sit in one firm. Plus, the 43-day average time-to-fill across roles means search moves fast.
- Best for: Carriers and insurtechs filling a C-suite seat fast, or bridging the gap with a fractional executive.
- Not a fit for: Boards that want a firm with a long public record of insurance CEO placements.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance practice within a cross-industry firm; Denver.
4. Korn Ferry

Korn Ferry ranked among the five largest executive search firms in the Americas in a 2022 ranking, and it backs search with assessment, succession planning, and leadership development.
Its insurance practice covers carriers, reinsurers, brokers, and industry associations. In September 2025, the firm named Liam Lawrence, a 25-year insurance search veteran, as Head of Insurance for North America, based in Chicago.
Korn Ferry's fiscal 2019 annual report describes its search work as focused on roles averaging $360,000 or more in annual cash compensation. That positions it squarely for top-of-house carrier mandates.
- Best for: Large carriers and reinsurers pairing a CEO or CFO search with leadership assessment of the bench.
- Not a fit for: Budget-limited searches below the C-suite.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Global insurance practice within a multi-industry firm; Los Angeles, with North American insurance leadership in Chicago.
5. Russell Reynolds Associates

Russell Reynolds Associates is a leadership advisory and search firm founded in New York in 1969, and its insurance work concentrates at the chair, CEO, and board level.
Its insurance consultants, such as Tom Hicks, recruit non-executive directors, CEOs, CFOs, chief underwriting officers, and claims directors across general, specialty, and life and retirement insurers.
The firm is a frequent choice for governance-heavy mandates, where a search committee needs board succession advice alongside the search itself. Its most visible recent insurance work is in the London market (appointed by Lloyd’s), so US buyers should ask for comparable domestic placements.
- Best for: Listed insurance groups searching for a chair, CEO, or independent directors.
- Not a fit for: Mid-market carriers that need hands-on search below the C-suite.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance practice within a multi-industry firm; New York.
6. Caldwell

Caldwell is a Toronto-headquartered, TSX-listed retained search firm whose insurance practice is led out of Stamford, Connecticut.
The practice grew through the acquisition of Hawksmoor Search, a London insurance and reinsurance boutique, which gave Caldwell insurance partners in London, Stamford, New York, Dallas, Toronto, Vancouver, and Calgary.
The firm recruited a chief customer experience officer for Western Financial Group Insurance Solutions.
Its stated insurance client base spans stock companies, mutual insurers, regional and super-regional carriers, fraternal insurers, captives, and PE portfolio companies. That breadth fits a North American carrier hiring across the US-Canada border or recruiting from the London and Bermuda markets.
- Best for: North American carriers and fraternal or mutual insurers hiring across the US and Canada.
- Not a fit for: Brokers that need high-volume producer recruiting.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance practice within a multi-industry firm; Toronto.
Best Insurance Recruiters for PE-Backed Brokers, MGAs, and Insurtechs
These three firms work where insurance hiring follows deals: broker roll-ups, MGA platforms, TPAs, and insurtechs that need leaders who can run a business against a sponsor's value-creation plan.
For sponsor-backed searches outside insurance, see our guide to private equity executive search firms.
1. JM Search

JM Search is a retained firm built around private equity and growth-stage companies.
Its insurance team works across carriers, brokers, MGAs and MGUs, TPAs, claims organizations, reinsurance intermediaries, and insurtech data platforms. That segment list tracks where sponsor capital has flowed in insurance distribution and services.
The firm says its partners stay involved in every step of each search, and its team includes former C-level executives. JM Search was named to Hunt Scanlon's Private Equity Recruiting Power 100 and reports placing nearly 1,500 executives in 24 months, a firm-wide figure.
- Best for: PE-backed brokers, MGAs, and TPAs hiring a CEO, CFO, or COO after an acquisition.
- Not a fit for: Mutual carriers that want a firm steeped in policyholder-owned governance.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance practice within a PE-focused search firm; King of Prussia, Pennsylvania.
2. Kaye/Bassman International

Kaye/Bassman International runs a dedicated insurance and risk management practice inside a multi-practice search firm founded in 1981. The practice focuses on retail and wholesale insurance brokerages of every size, placing executives, commercial lines managers, employee benefits consultants, wholesale brokers, and producers.
Kaye/Bassman offers both retained and contingency search, which gives a brokerage room to fund a CEO search differently from a regional leader hire.
The firm, based in Plano, Texas, now sits within Starfish Partners, an ownership platform for specialist search firms, and reports being the largest single-site search firm in the US.
- Best for: Retail and wholesale brokerages hiring branch, practice, or regional leaders alongside producers.
- Not a fit for: Carrier boards searching for a CEO or independent directors.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance and risk management practice within a multi-practice firm; Plano, Texas.
3. Capstone Search Group

Capstone Search Group has recruited only for the insurance industry since 2002, from Urbandale, Iowa. Its clients include carriers, agencies, retail and wholesale brokers, MGAs, MGUs, TPAs, program administrators, BPO providers, and insurance software companies, across all 50 states.
Most of its work is direct hire, with executive search, contract staffing, and recruitment process outsourcing alongside, so it best fits leadership roles one level below the C-suite.
Co-founder Scot Dickerson worked in insurance before moving into recruiting, and the firm lists the Certified Personnel Consultant (CPC) credential.
- Best for: MGAs, program administrators, and regional carriers hiring underwriting, claims, or branch leadership.
- Not a fit for: CEO or board searches at large carriers.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Insurance-only; Urbandale, Iowa. CPC credential listed.
Best Specialty Insurance Executive Recruiters
These two firms cover seats that generalist search firms handle less: leadership in the Lloyd's and London specialty market, and the actuarial function that prices and reserves every policy.
1. Stanton Chase (Best for London-Market)

Stanton Chase is a Baltimore-headquartered retained firm whose global insurance practice is centered in the City of London, which the firm calls the world's largest insurance and investment market.
In 2010, it opened a London City office devoted solely to international insurance and reinsurance, staffed by a team that had worked together for more than a decade.
Its insurance consultants recruit CEOs, COOs, chief commercial officers, CFOs, CMOs, and CTOs. In 2024, Stanton Chase became the first search firm to trademark its executive search methodology, and it is a member of the Association of Executive Search Consultants (AESC).
- Best for: US carriers, MGAs, and reinsurers recruiting leaders from the Lloyd's and London specialty market.
- Not a fit for: Personal lines carriers hiring within one US region.
- Insurance focus and HQ: London-centered insurance practice within a multi-industry firm; Baltimore. AESC member.
2. DW Simpson (Best for Actuarial Leadership)

DW Simpson recruits only actuaries and the analytics professionals who work beside them, from students to Fellows, across property and casualty, life, health, and pension.
Founded in 1989 in Chicago and led by CEO Patty Simpson, it has expanded into catastrophe modeling, predictive modeling, financial modeling, and data science, which now sit inside many insurers' pricing and reserving functions.
At the time of writing, its open roles include director-level actuarial positions at global insurers, typically hybrid across several US cities.
- Best for: Carriers and reinsurers hiring a chief actuary, appointed actuary, or head of pricing or reserving.
- Not a fit for: Any non-actuarial executive seat.
- Insurance focus and HQ: Actuarial and insurance analytics only; Chicago.
- Verifiable insurance mandate: DW Simpson posts anonymized client roles, such as a personal lines Actuary & Director for a global insurer, and does not name clients.
How Do the Top Insurance Executive Search Firms Compare?
Three of the 11 firms recruit only for insurance or actuarial roles; the other eight run an insurance practice inside a multi-industry firm. Use the engagement model column to rule firms in or out before the first call.
How Does an Insurance Executive Search Work?
An insurance executive search runs in five stages, from scoping the role to clearing the new officer with regulators, and a senior search usually takes three to six months. The regulatory step sets insurance apart from most other industries.
Step 1: Define the Role and the Success Profile
The firm and the hiring committee agree on the role's line of business, reporting lines, the results expected in the first 24 months, and the compensation range. For an insurance seat, the profile should name the specific products, distribution channels, and regulatory exposure the leader will own.
Step 2: Map Talent at Competitor Carriers, Brokers, and MGAs
The search team builds a target list of companies and named executives in comparable roles. This is also when off-limits rules surface, covered in the questions section below.
Step 3: How Search Firms Find Passive Insurance Candidates
Most strong candidates are employed and not looking. The firm approaches them confidentially, screens for interest and fit, and presents a shortlist of finalists who have already confirmed interest.
Step 4: Assessment, References, and Regulatory Approval of Officers
Finalists undergo structured interviews, leadership assessments, and reference checks. Insurance adds one more check.
Domestic insurers in states such as Maine and Washington must file an NAIC Biographical Affidavit (Form 11) for any new director, officer, or key managerial person.
In New York, an NAIC-approved independent third party must verify those affidavits. A candidate with a disclosure issue can stall an appointment, so a strong search firm screens for it before the offer.
Step 5: Offer, Resignation Management, and Onboarding
The firm helps structure the offer, manages counteroffers and notice periods, and checks for non-compete or non-solicit terms. Good firms stay in touch through the first months in the role.
How Long an Insurance Executive Search Takes
Plan for three to six months for a CEO or C-suite seat.
When WellPoint retained Spencer Stuart for its CEO search, the company said it expected the search to take three to six months.
Director-level searches with a clear candidate market can close faster, while board and London-market searches often run longer.
Should You Hire an Insurance-Only Boutique or a Global Retained Search Firm?
Choose an insurance-only boutique when the seat needs deep line-of-business knowledge, and a global retained firm when it needs board-level reach or candidates from outside the US. A third group, PE-focused and cross-industry firms, fits seats where the best candidate may not come from insurance at all.
Off-limits rules deserve the most attention, and the questions section below covers how to check them.
Many insurers split the work. They use a global firm for the CEO and board, an insurance-only boutique for underwriting, claims, and actuarial leaders, and a cross-industry firm for technology seats. Splitting by seat also limits how much of the market any one firm's off-limits list can close.
How Much Do Insurance Executive Search Firms Charge?
A retained insurance executive search usually costs about one-third of the hire's first-year cash compensation, and a contingency search for a director-level role usually costs 15% to 25% of first-year salary, according to Staffing Industry Analysts data.
How Much Does a Retained Insurance Executive Search Cost?
Retained firms typically charge about one-third of the role's first-year annual cash compensation, whether or not the position is filled.
The fee is usually paid in three installments: at signing, at shortlist, and at placement.
Some firms calculate the fee on total first-year compensation, so a bonus target and first-year equity can raise the base the percentage applies to. Confirm which components count before you sign.
How Much Do Contingency Recruiters Charge for Insurance Roles?
Contingency firms are paid only when their candidate is hired, at the rate above. Kaye/Bassman and Capstone Search Group offer contingency or direct-hire terms, which can suit underwriting, claims, and regional leadership roles below the C-suite.
Contingency firms usually work non-exclusively, so expect less market mapping than a retained search delivers.
How Are Interim and Fractional Insurance Executives Billed?
Interim and fractional executives are billed by the day, week, or month for a defined period, with the rate agreed per engagement.
The Jacobson Group offers interim experts, and Alpha Apex Group offers fractional and interim executives. These suit a carrier covering a vacancy during a permanent search, or a growing MGA that needs a part-time CFO or chief risk officer before it can justify a full-time hire.
What Should You Ask an Insurance Executive Search Firm Before You Sign?
Five questions separate a firm that knows your seat from one that will learn on your fee. Ask every firm on your shortlist the same five, in writing, and compare the answers side by side.
Comparable Placements in Your Line of Business
Ask: "Which comparable roles have you filled in the last two years, in our line of business?"
A personal lines carrier, a specialty MGA, and a life and annuity writer recruit from different talent pools. A good answer names roles, segments, and at least two references you can call. Generic claims about "deep insurance expertise" are not an answer.
Who Runs the Search Day to Day
Ask: "Which partner will lead our search, and how many other searches is that partner running?"
Senior partners often win the engagement and hand the work to associates. Get the lead partner's name in the contract, and ask how often you will get a written status update.
Off-Limits and Client-Conflict Restrictions
Ask: "Which companies can you not recruit from for this search?"
Ask for the list in writing. A firm usually agrees not to recruit executives from its current clients.
If your three closest competitors are off-limits, the firm cannot approach the executives most likely to fit, and no amount of process makes up for that. This matters most with global firms and insurance-only boutiques, which tend to have many insurer clients.
Regulatory Vetting for Insurance Officers and Directors
Ask: "How do you screen finalists for the disclosures in the NAIC Biographical Affidavit?"
As covered in the process section above, many state regulators require a filed and verified affidavit for new officers and directors. A firm that screens for regulatory, litigation, and credit issues before the offer protects you from a stalled appointment.
Fees, Guarantees, and Replacement Terms
Ask: "What is the fee basis, what is the payment schedule, and what happens if the hire leaves early?"
Confirm whether the fee covers base salary only or total compensation, whether expenses are capped, and how long the replacement guarantee runs. Retained firms may offer guarantees of up to 12 months, sometimes with one free re-search, while contingency guarantees are usually shorter.
Match the Search Firm to the Seat You Are Filling
The right insurance executive search firm is the one whose network already covers the seat. Use global firms for CEO, chair, and board seats, insurance-only boutiques for line-of-business depth, and PE-focused or cross-industry firms when the company is sponsor-backed, or the seat can come from outside insurance.
Shortlist two or three firms from the matcher at the top of this guide. Then put the same five questions to each, starting with off-limits restrictions, and choose the firm that can approach the candidates you actually want.
Insurance Executive Search FAQ
Who are the big 5 executive search firms, and do they all recruit insurance executives?
The big five are Korn Ferry, Russell Reynolds Associates, Spencer Stuart, Heidrick & Struggles, and Egon Zehnder, the five largest by revenue in a 2022 ranking of Americas search firms. Korn Ferry, Russell Reynolds, and Spencer Stuart are profiled above because each has named insurance practice partners. Heidrick & Struggles and Egon Zehnder were not profiled on this list.
Is an executive search firm worth the fee for an insurance leadership hire?
For a CEO or C-suite seat, usually yes. A bad executive hire can cost 50% to 200% of the executive's annual salary, according to SHRM, which is more than a typical one-third retained fee. A firm also adds confidential access to passive candidates and screens for the regulatory disclosures insurers must file.
Is retained or contingency search better for insurance leadership roles?
Retained search fits CEO, C-suite, and board roles, where the firm works exclusively, maps the market, and approaches employed executives. Contingency search fits director-level underwriting, claims, and branch roles, where several candidates are already in the market. Some firms on this list, including Kaye/Bassman, offer both.
Why are insurance leadership searches harder in 2026?
The strongest insurance leaders are staying put. In the Q3 2026 Insurance Labor Market Study by The Jacobson Group and Aon, 89% of carriers planned to increase or maintain staff, turnover slowed, and many were hiring to backfill key positions. Fewer executives on the move means more searches depend on approaching people who are not looking, which favors firms with deep insurance networks.
Are there executive recruiters that specialize in health insurance or life insurance?
Yes. For health insurance, Spencer Stuart and Korn Ferry have both led CEO searches at major health plans, and DW Simpson places health actuaries. For life insurance, The Jacobson Group, Russell Reynolds Associates, and Caldwell cover life, retirement, and fraternal insurers, and DW Simpson covers life and pension actuarial leadership.
For property and casualty (P&C), The Jacobson Group and Caldwell run carrier C-suite searches, and Kaye/Bassman covers commercial lines leadership at brokerages.
