November 16, 2026

Best Investment Banking Recruiters: 10 Firms Compared by Deal Seniority

Best Investment Banking Recruiters: 10 Firms Compared by Deal Seniority

Investment banking recruiters earn their fee on the hires a bank can't make through its own network: a healthcare M&A vice president who has run sell-side processes, a leveraged finance team ready to move together, or a group head for a new office. Each search calls for a different kind of firm.

Some recruiters work the analyst-to-director market on contingency and can run several searches at once. Others run retained, confidential searches for managing directors and division heads. 

Choosing from the wrong group adds weeks to a hire in a market where most senior candidates still have to serve out notice before they can start.

This guide compares 10 investment banking recruiters and executive search firms, grouped by the seniority each serves best. 

Quick Comparison: Who Are the Best Investment Banking Recruiters?

Selby Jennings, Dartmouth Partners, and Maven Partnership ranked first, second, and third for investment banking in the eFinancialCareers 2026 survey. 

The table compares them with seven specialist and executive search firms by seniority and office. 

Firm Segment HQ IB hub offices Seniority focus Best for
Russell Reynolds Associates Executive search New York New York, London, plus 44 other offices MD, division head, C-suite Confidential global leadership searches
Alpha Apex Group Executive search Denver Denver, Montreal VP to C-suite, interim leaders Leadership search paired with interim cover
Options Group Executive search New York New York, London, Hong Kong, Singapore, Tokyo Director to MD Senior front-office hires with pay benchmarking
Sheffield Haworth Executive search London London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai MD and group head Market mapping before a senior hire
Hudson Gate Partners Executive search New York (21 W 46th St) New York COO, CFO, legal, technology leads Non-deal leadership inside banks
Selby Jennings Specialist recruiter New York (600 Lexington Ave) New York, London, Zurich, Singapore, Hong Kong Analyst to director Parallel hiring across several deal teams
Dartmouth Partners Specialist recruiter London London, New York, Charlotte Analyst to director Transatlantic M&A and capital advisory hires
Maven Partnership Specialist recruiter New York New York, London, Dubai, Hong Kong VP to MD, full teams Team lifts and divisional build-outs
Harrison Rush Group Specialist recruiter New York (100 Church St) New York Associate to MD Sector coverage hires at boutique banks
Robin Judson Partners Specialist recruiter New York New York Associate to director Restructuring and capital markets roles

How We Chose These Investment Banking Recruiting Firms

We screened firms against four inclusion criteria:

  • Investment banking is a named practice. The firm runs a dedicated investment banking or global banking practice, or IB is one of a handful of core sectors. We excluded generalist agencies that list banking among dozens of industries. 
  • Verified presence. We checked each firm's headquarters and offices against team bios, live job postings, press coverage, and published addresses.
  • It recruits into banks. We excluded firms whose main business is moving bankers into private equity and hedge fund seats, since this guide is for banks that are hiring. 
  • Signals beyond the firm's own website. We used the eFinancialCareers survey, Hunt Scanlon coverage, and each firm's published research where available. Any figures a firm reports about itself are labeled as self-reported.

Entries are grouped by two seniority levels. Alpha Apex Group publishes this guide and is included in the executive category, reviewed against the same criteria as others.

Pro Tip: Broader finance leadership searches are covered in our guide to the best finance executive search firms.

Best Investment Banking Executive Search Firms for MD and Group Head Searches

These five investment banking executive recruiters take on managing director, group head, and leadership mandates, most of them on a retained basis. They suit banks building a new team or replacing a senior leader.

1. Russell Reynolds Associates

Russell Reynolds Associates website

Russell Reynolds Associates is a global leadership advisory and search firm whose Global Banking and Markets practice runs senior searches across investment banking, capital markets advisory, and corporate banking. 

The practice is led from London by Sophie Saeed, who spent seven years in investment banking at Goldman Sachs, most recently as an executive director in leveraged finance.

Recent mandates include sector, country, and product advisory leadership roles for global banks and independent boutiques. The firm pairs search with board and CEO succession work, which helps when an MD hire is also a step in a bank's leadership pipeline.

Best for: Global banks and large boutiques hiring division, regional, or group heads under strict confidentiality.

Not a fit for: Hires below MD, where a retained fee on a senior scale rarely pays off.

2. Alpha Apex Group

Alpha Apex Group website

Alpha Apex Group's investment banking executive search combines strategic talent mapping, custom recruitment strategy, and candidate assessment for banks hiring at VP level and above.

The firm also places interim and fractional executives and runs recruitment process outsourcing, so a bank can cover a vacant COO or CFO seat while a permanent leadership search runs. And its M&A executive search team works the adjacent corporate development market. 

Recruiters at Alpha Apex Group highlight first candidates within 72 hours, helping the search move faster than typical executive headhunting practices in the banking industry. 

Best for: Investment banks pairing a permanent leadership search with interim cover, or hiring across banking and corporate development seats.

Not a fit for: Investment banks that want a recruiter specifically with a staffed office in New York or London.

3. Options Group

Options Group website

Options Group has run financial services executive search from New York since 1992, and its Gramercy Park headquarters houses about 80 staff. 

Its consultants work across investment banking, capital markets, and global markets, and the firm reports more than 10,000 financial services placements since its founding.

It also publishes an annual Global Financial Markets Overview & Compensation Report, and the 2025/2026 edition added middle-market advisory investment banking pay tables. That data helps a bank price a senior offer before the search starts, so finalists are less likely to walk over compensation late in the process.

Best for: Banks hiring directors and MDs that want pay benchmarks to anchor the offer.

Not a fit for: Analyst and associate hiring, which sits below the firm's focus.

4. Sheffield Haworth

Sheffield Haworth website

Sheffield Haworth was founded in London in 1993 as a financial services search specialist and opened its New York office in 2004 to build a US investment banking business. 

It now employs more than 200 people across 15 offices, and its Global Banking practice works alongside markets, asset management, and corporate officers teams.

Beyond search, the firm runs leadership advisory and information and data services that map a target market before outreach begins. For a bank deciding whether to build a sector team or hire one, that map shows who is available and at what level.

Best for: Banks entering a new sector or city that need a market map before committing to a senior hire.

Not a fit for: Fast, single-seat junior hires.

5. Hudson Gate Partners

Hudson Gate Partners website

Hudson Gate Partners focuses on non-investment leadership roles at investment banks, private equity firms, hedge funds, and venture capital firms, covering management, finance, legal, technology, and infrastructure hires. 

Founder Dana Feller spent more than ten years at Lehman Brothers, including a stint as head of recruiting for European investment banking, then worked as a principal at Heidrick & Struggles on investment banking searches.

Its infrastructure team builds out accounting, compliance, operations, and human resources functions, and a separate practice covers data science and AI roles. It suits banks hiring the people who keep deal teams running.

Best for: Banks hiring a COO, CFO, general counsel, or head of technology.

Not a fit for: Front-office deal roles such as coverage or product bankers.

Top Specialist Investment Banking Recruiters for Analyst-to-Director Hiring

These five investment banking recruitment firms handle most of the market's analyst, associate, VP, and director moves. They suit banks filling seats inside existing deal teams.

1. Selby Jennings

Selby Jennings website

Selby Jennings is the financial services recruitment brand of Phaidon International, and it topped the investment banking category of the eFinancialCareers 2026 Ideal Recruiter survey by a wide margin.

Its US investment banking desk works with bulge bracket institutions and boutique advisory platforms, and its live New York roles span industrials, healthcare, and restructuring teams from analyst to vice president. 

Offices in New York, London, Zurich, Singapore, and Hong Kong let it run several searches in parallel, which suits a bank adding associates to three or four coverage groups in the same quarter.

Best for: Middle-market and elite boutique banks hiring analysts and associates into several groups at once.

Not a fit for: A confidential group head search, where a small retained team limits who knows about the role.

2. Dartmouth Partners

Dartmouth Partners website

Dartmouth Partners ranked second for investment banking in the same eFinancialCareers survey. 

Former PwC analyst Logan Naidu founded the firm in London in 2012, and it now runs offices in New York and Charlotte, so US banks get a recruiter with a working London bench for cross-border teams.

Its investment banking practice covers integrated and independent banks, and its consultants send clients compensation updates through the year. Recent New York mandates include associate seats on a capital advisory team that raises debt for funds, insurers, lenders, and fintech businesses.

Best for: US banks hiring for teams that execute deals alongside London colleagues, plus Charlotte-based banking groups.

Not a fit for: Banks hiring in Asia or continental Europe, where the firm lists no office.

3. Maven Partnership

Maven Partnership website

Maven Partnership, previously Maven Search, has a Global Banking & Markets practice that sits alongside investment management, private capital, and technology teams, with offices in New York, West Palm Beach, London, Dubai, and Hong Kong.

The firm reports more than 1,000 completed executive searches, including whole-firm acquisitions, global team moves, and multi-year divisional build-outs. 

That team-move experience matters when a bank enters a new sector, where hiring one MD usually means hiring the VPs and associates who work with them.

Best for: Banks lifting out a coverage team or building a new division across several levels.

Not a fit for: A single junior hire, where a high-volume specialist will move faster.

4. Harrison Rush Group

Harrison Rush Group website

The Harrison Rush Group is a New York boutique that recruits investment banking, private equity, and corporate development talent.

Its open mandates at the time of writing show how granular its coverage-group work gets: a FIG associate for a global bank, a vice president in equity capital markets, an infrastructure software MD for an upper middle-market bank, and a TMT director for an elite boutique in San Francisco. 

Many postings publish pay ranges, which gives hiring banks a live read on where compensation is clearing.

Best for: Boutique and middle-market banks hiring sector bankers into named coverage groups, associate through MD.

Not a fit for: Hiring outside the US, since the firm works from a single New York office.

5. Robin Judson Partners

Robin Judson Partners website

Robin Judson Partners opened in New York in fall 2010 and recruits for investment banks, hedge funds, and private equity firms. 

Founder Robin Judson started as a Merrill Lynch research analyst and brought 25 years of financial services recruiting experience to launch, placing candidates in restructuring advisory, corporate finance, and distressed credit roles.

Her team includes managing directors who previously recruited for capital markets desks at Smith Hanley Associates. That background fits restructuring and liability management groups best, since their candidates often move between advisory work and distressed investing.

Best for: Restructuring, liability management, and capital markets teams hiring at associate to director level.

Not a fit for: Large multi-level hiring programs, given the firm's boutique size.

Which Investment Banking Roles Do Recruiters Fill?

Investment banking recruiters fill front-office deal roles from analyst to managing director, plus the non-deal leaders who run a bank's operations. 

Most searches are defined by two things: the group the hire joins and the level they join at.

Role group Typical seats Who usually runs the search
Industry coverage FIG, TMT, healthcare, industrials, energy and infrastructure bankers Specialist recruiters through director; executive search for group heads
Product groups M&A, leveraged finance, ECM, DCM, restructuring, private capital advisory Specialist recruiters through director; executive search for product heads
Senior leadership Managing directors, group heads, division and regional heads Retained executive search
Non-deal leadership COO, CFO, general counsel, CTO, compliance and operations heads Executive search firms with a corporate officers practice

Product-group depth varies widely between firms. Selby Jennings, for example, names M&A, restructuring, leveraged finance, ECM, DCM, and private capital advisory as the areas where banks most need specialist market knowledge. 

Ask every firm on your shortlist which of these groups it has placed into in the past 12 months.

How Much Do Investment Banking Recruiters Charge?

Investment banking recruiters typically charge 20% to 33% of a hire's first-year compensation. How the fee is calculated matters as much as the percentage.

Model Typical fee When it's paid Usual seniority
Contingency 20% to 30% of first-year pay Only when a candidate accepts Analyst to director
Retained About one-third of first-year cash compensation In installments from engagement to placement MD, group head, leadership

On the contingency side, 20% is the most common direct-hire fee in North America, charged by 42% of staffing firms in a Staffing Industry Analysts survey. 

Published terms run higher. For instance, Robert Walters' New York terms set a 30% default. 

Bonuses make the fee basis a major cost driver in banking. Robert Walters' terms count guaranteed bonuses in full and non-guaranteed bonuses at two-thirds of the likely amount.

Take a VP with a $300,000 base and a $300,000 expected bonus: a 30% fee on base alone is $90,000, while 30% on base plus two-thirds of the bonus is $150,000. 

Agree on the fee basis in writing before the first resume arrives.

How to Select an Investment Banking Recruiter

The right investment banking recruiter has placed into your product or coverage group recently, can reach the banks you want to hire from, and has terms that hold up if the hire leaves early. 

Check these six areas before you sign.

Match the firm to the seat

Specialist recruiters move faster on analyst-to-director hires, and retained search firms protect confidentiality on MD and group head searches. A retained firm on a single associate seat wastes fees, and a volume recruiter on a group head search risks the role leaking to the market.

Ask: "What share of your investment banking placements last year were at this level?"

Test product and coverage-group depth

A recruiter who places healthcare M&A bankers every quarter knows who is unhappy, who just got passed over, and what a move costs. One who places across all of financial services may not.

Ask: "Which placements have you made in this group over the past 12 months, and at which kinds of banks?"

Get the off-limits list before you sign

Most search firms agree not to recruit from their own clients for a set period. The AESC's guide to choosing a search firm lists off-limits terms among the points to settle in the engagement letter. A firm that serves many large banks may be blocked from approaching your top target banks entirely.

Ask: "Which banks are off-limits to you for this search, and until when?"

Plan for notice periods and garden leave

Senior bankers typically don’t start the week after they sign. eFinancialCareers reports that bankers moving jobs in the City of London commonly take at least three months of gardening leave, and US notice periods and non-competes add their own delays. A good recruiter maps each finalist's restrictions early and manages counteroffers through the notice period.

Ask: "How do you handle counteroffers and start dates for candidates on garden leave?"

Price in deferred-compensation buyouts

Senior bankers usually forfeit unvested bonus awards when they resign, and the hiring bank often covers the loss. The UK's FCA has called the cancellation of unvested awards for staff who leave for a competitor a widespread practice, and new employers often agree to compensate for it.

At the top end, the sums are large. For instance, Wells Fargo's CFO offer letter paired a $900,000 cash sign-on with $5,422,030 in restricted shares to replace forfeited pay.

Ask: "How much unvested deferred pay will each finalist forfeit, and how did you confirm it?"

Agree the fee basis, guarantee, and candidate claim

The fee percentage is only one line of the contract. Robert Walters' New York terms, for example, offer a replacement search within 12 weeks and no cash refund, and charge the fee on any introduced candidate hired within 12 months.

Ask: "Is the guarantee a refund or a replacement search, and how long can you claim a candidate you introduced?"

Your Next Step: Shortlist Three Investment Banking Recruiters

Three well-briefed firms are enough to run most investment banking searches. Four steps get you there.

  1. Define the seat. Write down the group, level, city, and the latest start date you can accept once notice periods are counted.
  2. Pick three firms. Include at least one specialist recruiter, and add a retained search firm for any MD or group head role.
  3. Send all three the same brief. Ask each the selection questions above, starting with which banks are off-limits for this search.
  4. Compare terms side by side. Line up the fee basis, guarantee, and candidate claim period before you sign anything.

Alpha Apex Group can help your organization headhunt reliable leadership with investment banking experience for both permanent placement and interim cover. 

Get in touch to schedule a consultation.

FAQs

Do investment banks use headhunters for analyst and associate hires?

Yes, mainly for lateral hires. First-year analyst classes usually come through campus programs, but banks use recruiters to fill experienced analyst and associate seats mid-year. Selby Jennings' New York listings, for example, have included an experienced analyst seat on an upper middle-market industrials team.

What's the difference between an investment banking recruiter and an executive search firm?

Investment banking recruiters usually work on contingency, are paid only when a hire is made, and focus on analyst-to-director seats. Executive search firms usually work on retainer, are paid in installments, and run exclusive, confidential searches for MDs, group heads, and leadership roles. Some firms offer both models, so ask which one applies to your search.

How long does an investment banking lateral search take with garden leave?

Plan for the search and the notice period together. The SHRM 2025 recruiting benchmarking brief put average time to fill at about a month and a half across roles. London bankers commonly add three months or more of gardening leave. From brief to first day, a senior lateral hire can take four months or longer.

‍

Additional Reading

October 30, 2026
Best Hedge Fund Recruiters for 2026, Matched by Role

This guide compares 13 hedge fund recruiters for portfolio management, investment, compliance, operations, and C-suite hiring, with role-specific recommendations and recruiter fees.

Read More
October 30, 2026
12 Best Renewable Energy Recruiters, Sorted by the Hire You Need

This guide compares 12 renewable energy recruiters, executive search firms, and staffing agencies for technical, leadership, and project-based hiring.

Read More
October 19, 2026
How to Hire a Private Equity CFO: Process, Profile, and Pay

A practical guide to hiring a private equity CFO, covering when to hire, key qualifications, executive search steps, and salary and equity benchmarks.

Read More
October 15, 2026
COO Salary & Compensation Guide 2026

Compare 2026 COO salaries, bonuses, equity, and total compensation across startups, private equity backed firms, and public companies.

Read More
October 15, 2026
Petroleum Engineer Salary: A Detailed Guide

The median petroleum engineer salary is $144,910. Compare pay by experience, state, industry, and employer using the latest BLS data and salary benchmarks.

Read More
October 15, 2026
CFO Job Description Template: Responsibilities, KPIs & Reporting Lines

With CFO turnover projected at 18.3% in 2026, use this CFO job description template to define responsibilities, KPIs, reporting lines, and hiring criteria.

Read More
October 9, 2026
What Is a PE Operating Partner? Role, Comp & How to Hire One

PE operating partners drive portfolio company performance and value creation. This guide covers their responsibilities, compensation, operating models, and hiring process.

Read More
September 8, 2026
Top 10 Colorado Manufacturing Recruiters with ITAR Compliance Expertise

Only 3 of the 10 Colorado manufacturing recruiters reviewed publicly document ITAR-specific expertise, making the distinction critical for defense and aerospace employers.

Read More
September 3, 2026
HRIS Selection: A Complete Guide for HR Leaders in 2026

Nearly one-third of HR leaders regret their latest HR technology purchase. This guide shows how to make a smarter HRIS selection in 2026.

Read More

Whether you're searching for talent or need expert consulting, we're here to help.

Contact Us